Thursday, June 8, 2017

2017 Instant Replay - Status Report at Review No. 500

500 Replay Reviews into the 2017 regular season, here is a status report of how baseball's video review system has fared this year, including a list of Replay Reviews which Assistant Commissioner tmac has identified as erroneous in outcome (e.g., upheld or reversed in contravention of video evidence):

Replay Review Decisions: 500 (6/7/17).
Total Upheld: 250 (50.0%).
Total Overturned: 250 (50.0%).

Leaderboard - Top 10 Umpires*
RAPUmpireRank
100.0%Carapazza, Vic (4/4) 1
90.9%Marquez, Alfonso (10/11)2
87.5%West, Joe (7/8)3
85.7%Guccione, Chris (6/7)4
83.3%Foster, Marty (5/6)5
80.0%Everitt, Mike (4/5)6
77.8%Porter, Alan (7/9)7
75.0%Cuzzi, Phil (6/8)8
75.0%Hoye, James (3/4)8
75.0%Baker, Jordan (3/4)8

By Reason of Review / Type of Play
RAPTypeRank
.857Fair/Foul1
.833Slide Interference2
.681HR/In Play3
.667Runner Placement4
.598Out/Safe (Tag - into Base)5
.553Out/Safe (Pulled Foot)6
.529Out/Safe (Force - Second)7
.500HBP/No HBP8
.500Out/Safe (Appeal)8
.500Foul Ball/Fan INT8
.500Appeal Play (Missed Base)8

Leaderboard - Team
RAPTypeRank
.786KC1
.714SF2
.692BAL3
.688NYM4
.688NYY4
.643PIT6
.632LAD7
.600LAA8
.593TEX9
.588CHC10
.583CWS11
.563ARI12
.556CLE13
.500CIN14
.500HOU14
.500MIN14
.471COL17
.462PHI18
.455WAS19
.429SEA20
.409ATL21
.400TB22
.381STL23
.368BOS24
.364TOR25
.357DET26
.357MIA26
.333MIL28
.308OAK29
.286SD30
Tmac's Replays-in-Error (Upheld or Overturned despite conflicting video evidence)
#On-Field Umpire   Dispo
001Hudson Upheld
024BellinoUpheld
100IassognaUpheld
102HamariUpheld
179CulbrethUpheld
183CederstromUpheld
198WestUpheld
199FaganUpheld
203NelsonUpheld
216EddingsUpheld
232ScheurwaterUpheld
238EmmelUpheld
302TimmonsUpheld
345HickoxOverturned
377WelkeUpheld
386WestUpheld
396CuzziUpheld
467Foster
Upheld
All except #216 and #396 were Out/Safe replays. #216 was a Foul Tip/HBP play. #396 was a HBP/No HBP play.

*Minimum number of Replay Reviews to qualify for the leaderboard was n=3. Other "Perfect Replay" Umpires under the minimum included Dale Scott, Chad Fairchild, and Ryan Blakney (all n=2), and Ramon De Jesus (n=1).

0 comments :

Post a Comment