Sunday, April 9, 2023

Odor Misses Home, Kim Scores, Odor Out on Appeal for Trying to Return to Touch a Missed Base

Padres baserunner Rougned Odor's 4th inning run against Atlanta was wiped off the board after a successful Braves appeal that Odor failed to touch home plate. HP Umpire Chad Fairchild declared Odor out even though replays show Odor returning to touch home plate. Why is that and how does Odor's teammate Ha-Seong Kim factor in?

With two on (R2, R3) and one out, Padres batter Trent Grisham hit a ground ball to Braves first baseman Matt Olson, who threw to catcher Travis d'Arnaud as Padres baserunner R3 Odor attempted to score from third base. Olson's throw evaded d'Arnaud's catcher's mitt and bounced to the backstop as Odor scampered past home plate and trailing baserunner R2 Kim jogged into score an apparent second run, after which R1 Odor, who had missed touching home plate his first time by, returned to touch the missed base.

After the play, however, Braves manager Brian Snitker spoke with HP Umpire Chad Fairchild and when the ball was put back into play, Braves pitcher Charlie Morton stepped off the rubber and threw to catcher d'Arnaud, who stepped on home plate and, after discussion, Umpire Fairchild ruled Odor out for failing to touch home plate.

Even though replays clearly indicate that Odor did return to touch home plate, he did so illegally.

Official Baseball Rule 5.09(c)(2) regarding appeal plays explains why Odor was out: "Any runner shall be called out on appeal when, with the ball in play, while advancing or returning to a base, they fail to touch each base in order before they, or a missed base, are tagged" while OBR 5.09(c)(2)'s Approved Ruling contains the answer key for this particular play: "No runner may return to touch a missed base after a following runner has scored."

Thus, Odor was called out because he returned to touch the missed base after following runner Kim had already scored, which is not allowed. This might sound akin to runners passing, but these two rules are distinct and different. For one, the Odor missed base play is an appeal play: Odor is not out unless the defense properly appeals (live ball appeals only in professional ball, etc.) while if this was a runners passing situation, Odor would have been declared out immediately upon the infraction (e.g., not an appeal play).

Video as follows:

Alternate Link: Odor fails to timely touch home plate as Braves appeal the missed base (SD/ATL)

0 comments :

Post a Comment